timothy falconer's semantic weblog
Big Fractal Tangle


RDF
 



the smirk of the nerd

It's been a while since I talked about "Grannies and Gurus", so before getting into the meat of what we're doing, it'll help to first define the audience we're aiming at.

Non-technical users are those that regularly put URLs in the Google search bar instead of the location bar. They're people who've never used a text editor in their life, only Word and email. Non-technical people rarely use menu bars. They're people who have yet to create a new folder in their email program, or even their file system. Non-technical people are the vast majority of computer users.

When I talk about this audience, most developers roll their eyes, though it's the audience we need if the semweb's gonna be more than a playground for large corporations and academic tweakers.

I see the semweb as a place where things aren't all that organized, where human inconsistency doesn't get in the way of doing useful things. What a terrific thing for those among us who have a tough time with hierarchies.

Here's an excerpt from an all-hands email I just sent, prompted by this post: "We should never appear superior to non-technical users. Always talk about such users as real people with geniune needs, even in our private planning sessions. Always suggest that it's our fault as software developers that things aren't easier. If others get confused, it's our failing, not theirs."

The smirk of the nerd is powerful force in our industry, one that holds back forward progress for everyone. Ten years ago, when the web was young, people slowly started asking us nerds to help "get them on the Internet." Remember how difficult PPP and browsers could be back then? Who benefited when it became easy for everyone? Everybody did.

Imagine if we could turn each smirk into a simple, smiling, "How can I help?" Imagine if we felt sadness rather than superior mirth as we told our tales of users who treat the CD tray as a drink holder. What's funny about the immaturity of our industry?

After all, there is no them. We all benefit when things are clear.




Trackbacks (use http://immuexa.com/cgi-bin/mtype/mt-tb.cgi/145)


Comments

Keep this in mind ALWAYS and you will have the ringing and powerful endorsement of Mr. Walter Mossberg. See: http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/12.05/mossberg.html He is a geek - but this is his mission statement and the clarion call that alienates High-Tech execs whenever they fail to execute on the vision. Personally - I love his stuff and adhere to his recommendations.

I've been pondering the smirk of the nerd (vis a vis culture) recently and - while I endorse your theory entirely - the rise of the nerd is entirely due to the internet. All of the obscure factoids we used to obsess/collaborate/discuss/ponder/argue about are now as open (if not MORE open) than the average telephone book.

We have won - but - OK - now all the stuff I found so interesting is boring in it's ubiquity.

The nerd enclave has become the same as the Mall. Even eBay has supplanted garage sales and flea markets (formerly the only culturally proper way to get a peek at the shit inside other people's houses). All of that is gone now - transparent and marketed to the Max.

You will NEVER lose by focusing on the customer - and might, indeed, do VERY well to find a 16 year old genius (like your younger self) as a paid intern. You might go through a few before finding the right one - but I'd bet you'd learn as much as he/she would.

In other words - the nerds won this round - but do we even know what the next round IS? Anarchy? Religious orthodoxy? My kids aren't yet old enough to indicate the trend - but your doppelganger sits in a room somewhere right now. And he or she would love to learn from you - maybe even earn a buck or two.

My two cents for tonight....

posted by Mike at May 17, 2004 04:43 AM